Mandatory attendance in college
has always been a highly debated subject. Should class attendance be mandatory?
Students, Professors say No.
Professors want students to
attend all of their classes so they can teach them directly, but many students
want to be given the freedom to decide which classes to attend. Due to the difficulty
of regulating a college-wide attendance policy, most colleges and universities
give professors the authority to set their own attendance rules.
“Nirav” as a student of university,
said he does not agree with mandatory attendance policies except in the case of
lab work because it is usually completed in class with very little work outside
of the classroom.
He noted that many professors say
regular attendance is necessary to do well in a course and agrees that
attendance and course performance are positively correlated.
“That being said, there would be
no need for mandatory attendance as students
seeking high grades will quickly learn that they need to attend the course
regularly,” he said. “Inflating grades
with 10-20 percent of your score coming from attendance is a poor judgment of
an individual’s competency in the course.”
Professor Mr. Shah who teaches
Maths at University and does not implement a mandatory attendance policy.
Instead, he gives his students the opportunity to earn participation points via
weekly quizzes and discussion questions. Interestingly more students are
interested in such policy. They generally come to class for actively
participation or discussion, though attendance is not mandatory.
This policy works well for Mr.
Shah and saves his lot of time and hassle.
“It’s beneficial to me because I
don’t have to worry about marking who’s there, who’s not, who’s late, who
leaves early,” he said. “Additionally, I don’t have to haggle with students
over any grades associated with ‘excused’ and ‘unexcused’ absences.”
While Mr. Shah’s non-mandatory
attendance policy makes his job easier, he’s not sure if it is beneficial to
his students. “I would hope it is since it suggests I’m treating them as adults,”
he said.
A common argument brought up by
students regarding mandatory attendance is that, as tuition payers, they
shouldn’t be punished for missing something they are paying for anyway.
“As students paying to enroll in
these courses, the attendance should be up to us and not roped into course
grading in any way shape or form,” Nirav said.
An additional aspect of mandatory
attendance that must be taken into consideration is the possible distraction caused by students who show up to class only
to earn credit points yet distract other students as they do everything
under the sun except listen to the professor. For instance, it is not uncommon
to go into a college lecture and see many students doing one of the following:
sleeping, Facebook chatting, online shopping, watching funny animal videos on
YouTube, streaming live sporting events etc…
“Tapan”, a student at University,
does not believe professors should allow students to get away with missing a
large number of classes. However, he also thinks a policy that requires
attendance to every class is too limiting. Instead, He thinks professors should
have mandatory attendance with a few absences allowed.
“I don’t think attendance should
be mandatory unless a few ‘free days’ are provided, because I think by the
university level, students have the right and responsibility to prioritize
their own time,” Tapan said. “I think it
would be unfair for a student to be penalized if they, for instance, chose to
forgo a lecture in favor of working on a semester project.”
Tapan said most of his professors
either don’t have an attendance policy or, if one is in place, students are
allowed to miss a certain number of days in the semester without being
penalized.
“I think this is preferable to a
more strict attendance policy, as it allows students appropriate control of
their own schedules,” he said.
While Tapan does not mind
professors who have attendance requirements, he recognizes that not all of his
peers share his opinion. He said he tries to regularly attend his classes to
learn from the lectures, but he knows there are many students who do not share
his learning style and would prefer to
learn the material on their own.
“For them, a strict attendance
policy seems detrimental,” he said.
In the end, Tapan believes
attendance policies must balance both sides and find a happy medium.
“We’re adults, but still college
students at the same time,” Tapan said. “Universities should have some
regulation, but we should be primarily responsible for our own education and I
think attendance policies should reflect that.”
